S3U

Reading / Media literacy / Grade 7 / re7v1

Visual Evidence: Beyond the Picture Border

Separate the part shown, the full drawing and a later caption claim.

All worksheets

Watch the lesson | Next: inspect a plan and its map key

5 questions0m 0s
Learn the skill

Describe visible details before interpreting them. Compare a crop with the complete image. Ask who wrote a caption, when it was added and what evidence supports it. An image date, an event date and a caption date can differ. Neither a confident label nor several copies makes an identification certain.

Worked example

A crop shows one occupied desk. The full sketch shows that desk and two empty desks. The crop does not establish a full room. A label added in 2000 says Exhibition, 1960, but supplies no source. The label records a claim; it does not by itself date the sketch or establish the event.

Full undated drawing: seven numbered chairs, 1-4 occupied, 5-7 empty. A dashed crop border keeps only chairs 1-4. A later caption was added in 1996 and claims Concert, 1956. No supporting source is supplied.
Question record: the chair drawing, not the worked-example desks. The dashed border marks crop B.

The fictional chair drawing

Drawing A is undated and has no event name. It depicts seven chairs: chairs 1-4 occupied and chairs 5-7 empty. Crop B keeps only chairs 1-4, without changing their details. No other seats or times are shown. A caption added in 1996 reads Concert, 1956. The folder does not identify the caption writer or provide evidence for that event and year. Two newsletters repeat the caption without adding sources. The drawing, caption and records are invented, not a real concert photograph.

Question 1 How many chairs in drawing A are outside crop B?
Question 2 Which statement stays within what the full drawing depicts?
Question 3 Do these records establish that the drawing depicts a concert in 1956?
Question 4 What does the supplied date 1996 belong to?
Question 5 Which new record would most directly help check the claimed event and year?