Give every physical tile its own name, even when shapes match. List the first tile, then the second. Returning the first tile restores every choice for the second draw. Count matching ordered pairs out of all allowed pairs. Exactly one star includes star then circle AND circle then star; two stars means both draws are stars. Reset the bag for each question.
Worked example
A separate worked bag has S1, C1 and C2. Return the first tile. Each of the 3 first tiles has 3 second choices, making 9 equally likely pairs. Only S1 then S1 gives two stars, so its chance is 1/9. S1 then C1 and C1 then S1 are different orders. The questions below use a different bag.