S3U

Reading / Media literacy / Grade 7 / re7v4

Visual Sources: The Garden Records

Apply the same source checks to a different drawing, caption and planning key.

All worksheets

Watch the lesson | Compare more records in Source Desk

Practice checking visual sources

5 questions0m 0s
Learn the skill

Count the full set and retained part before describing the crop. Distinguish an added label from proof of its claim. Use the supplied key even when it differs from a previous worksheet. Preserve the limits of time and place, and choose new evidence relevant to the exact claim.

Worked example

An undated sketch shows six lockers, four shut and two open. A crop keeps the four shut lockers, omitting two. A caption added in 2010 claims a 1980 visit, without support. A plan uses triangles for existing sheds and circles for proposed sheds. Neither a copied caption nor a proposed shed is proof of the claimed event or completed work.

Record A: nine benches, 1-5 occupied and 6-9 empty. Dashed crop keeps 1-5. Label added 2002 claims a 1972 festival without support. Record B: circles J, K and L mean existing fountains; triangles M and N mean proposed fountains. Dotted line is a proposed path. East-garden proposal dated 1964; not to scale.
Use the garden records. This plan uses a different key from the market plan.

Two invented garden records

Record A is an undated drawing of nine benches. Benches 1-5 are occupied; benches 6-9 are empty. A crop keeps only 1-5 unchanged. No other benches or times are shown. A label added in 2002 claims Garden festival, 1972, with no supporting source. Three notices copy it. Record B is a 1964 east-garden proposal, not to scale. Circles mean existing fountains J, K and L; triangles mean proposed fountains M and N. The dotted line means a proposed path. Only the east garden is covered, not all gardens. No completion or opening records are supplied.

Question 1 How many benches in the complete drawing are outside the crop?
Question 2 Which statement keeps the label date and event claim separate?
Question 3 According to record B, what do the triangles at M and N mean?
Question 4 Which conclusion stays within the records' stated coverage?
Question 5 What would most directly help check a claim that fountains M and N and the path opened in 1964?