S3U

Reading / Vocabulary / Grade 12 / rvc01

Analyze Diction and Unstated Assumptions

Examine how wording frames a proposal before evidence is considered.

All worksheets
5 questions0m 0s
Learn the skill

Identify evaluative words, the alternatives they imply, and any assumptions linking evidence to a conclusion. Test whether a neutral paraphrase preserves the facts while changing the persuasive framing.

Worked example

Calling a change a 'rescue' assumes that the current situation needs saving. A neutral phrase such as 'proposed revision' reports a change without deciding its value in advance.

Two Descriptions of One Proposal

Description A: 'At last, the committee will rescue the neglected courtyard by replacing its untidy planting beds with paving. The tidy space will finally be useful.' Description B: 'The committee proposes replacing the courtyard planting beds with paving. The proposal would reduce gardening space and increase the paved area. No usage counts or maintenance estimates accompany the proposal.'

1. What assumption is embedded in 'finally be useful'?
2. Which phrase carries the strongest positive framing of the change?
3. Which statement reports a consequence without endorsing it?
4. Which evidence would most directly test the assumption about present usefulness?
5. Which conclusion about the descriptions is justified?