S3U

Reading / Inference / Grade 7 / ri701

Separate a Narrator's Belief from Evidence

Evaluate a first-person explanation using details the narrator may overlook.

All worksheets
5 questions0m 0s
Learn the skill

List what the narrator directly observes, then separate interpretations of those observations. Consider an alternative explanation supported by the same passage. A narrator's confidence is not itself evidence.

Worked example

'They stopped talking when I entered, so they dislike me' combines an observation with an assumption. Preparing a surprise could explain the silence too, if other clues support it.

The Covered Poster

When I entered the club room, Jo covered a poster with a jacket. Clearly the club had decided to replace my design. I left before anyone could explain. Later, Jo sent a message asking how to spell my surname for the design credit. I still felt sure the jacket meant rejection, although I had never seen the poster beneath it.

1. Which statement is a direct observation?
2. Which later detail challenges the narrator's explanation?
3. Which alternative is plausible but not proven?
4. What limits the narrator's knowledge most directly?
5. Which conclusion fits the passage best?