S3U

Creativity / Story planning / Grade 9 / cp9cz

Test a Narrator Claim against Story Evidence - Practice 2

A narrator's account can be incomplete, mistaken or deliberately misleading.

All worksheets
5 questions0m 0s
Learn the skill

A narrator's account can be incomplete, mistaken or deliberately misleading. An inconsistency invites investigation rather than an instant diagnosis. These fictional excerpts supply a specific mismatch between a claim and another observation.

Worked example

A narrator says I never entered the room, but later describes reading the note on its desk that day. The mismatch raises a question; it does not by itself explain why.

A narrator says I never entered the room, but later describes reading the note on its desk that day. The mismatch raises a question; it does not by itself explain why.
A narrator says I never entered the room, but later describes reading the note on its desk that day. The mismatch raises a question; it does not by itself explain why.
Question 1 Fictional account 6: "No one spoke." Later a reply is quoted from the same moment. Which question targets the inconsistency?
Question 2 Fictional account 7: "I had forgotten the address." Later the narrator says the address was clear in memory. Which question targets the inconsistency?
Question 3 Fictional account 8: "The route was unfamiliar." Later the narrator claims to know every turn from earlier visits. Which question targets the inconsistency?
Question 4 Fictional account 9: "I never handled the key." Later the narrator describes putting it in a pocket. Which question targets the inconsistency?
Question 5 Fictional account 10: "The room was completely dark." Later the narrator reports seeing a tiny colored mark without another light. Which question targets the inconsistency?

Make It Your Own

Optional theme: a place that changes overnight. Write a short fictional account containing one deliberate gap or inconsistency. Add a note explaining two possible reasons a reader might consider. You may draw, write or tell your idea. Use invented characters and places; no personal information or upload is needed. This activity is not scored.

Reflect on your choices

  • Identify the textual mismatch without diagnosing the narrator.
  • Explain one intentional choice and one possible alternative.
  • There is no required style or single correct creative response.